← All Labour Law II Units Sem 5 · Labour Law II · Unit 5

Unit 5 — Exam Guide

4 detailed model answers covering the KSLU syllabus topics for Unit 5.

Q1
Explain the salient features and schemes under the Unorganised Workers' Social Security Act, 2008.
10 MarksMost Asked
▾
Summary💡 Easy Answer🗒 Mind Map✅ Key Points 8📖 Sections 7⚖ Cases 2⏰ Revision⚠ Emergency📝 Full Answer
Summary

The Unorganised Workers' Social Security Act, 2008 provides for the social security and welfare of unorganised workers โ€” home-based workers, self-employed workers and wage workers in the unorganised sector. It establishes the National Social Security Board (S.5) to recommend schemes covering life and disability cover, health and maternity benefits, old-age protection, and registration through identity cards (S.10). It gives effect to Article 41 and Article 43.

Easy Answer
Over 90% of India's workers are unorganised โ€” this Act gives them a safety net
Street vendors, construction workers, domestic workers, home-based workers
Who is covered? (S.2)
๐Ÿ  Home-based worker โ€” produces goods at home
๐Ÿง‘โ€๐Ÿ”ง Self-employed worker โ€” no hired labour, not in organised sector
๐Ÿ‘ท Wage worker โ€” works in unorganised sector for wages
๐ŸŽ‚ Age 14+ eligible for registration
Benefits (Schedule I schemes)
โค๏ธ Life & disability cover
๐Ÿฅ Health & maternity benefits
๐Ÿ‘ด Old age protection
๐Ÿ›ก๏ธ Other welfare measures
๐Ÿ†” Identity card via registration (S.10)
💡 Memory Trick: "NSSB-LHM-OID"
NSSB (Board, S.5) โ†’ recommends schemes • Life • Health & maternity • Old age • ID card (S.10) • Disability
Mind Map
Unorganised Workers' Act, 2008
Coverage (S.2)
Home-based, self-employed, wage
Applies to unorganised workers. Home-based worker: produces goods or services at home. Self-employed: not employing hired labour. Wage worker: in unorganised sector. Excludes workers covered by other statutes like ESI, EPF.
Boards (S.5-6)
National & State Boards
National Social Security Board chaired by Union Labour Minister: recommends schemes, monitors, advises. State Social Security Boards (S.6) advise on state-level schemes and coordinate with Centre.
Schemes (S.3)
Welfare schemes
Central Government formulates welfare schemes in Schedule I: life and disability cover, health and maternity benefits, old age protection. State Governments may frame schemes on housing, education, skill upgradation and provident fund.
Registration (S.10)
Identity card
Every unorganised worker aged 14 years and above can register with the District Administration, submitting a self-declaration. District Administration issues an identity card. Registration is the gateway to benefits.
Key Points
  • Objective: To provide for social security and welfare of unorganised workers โ€” implements Articles 41 and 43.
  • Section 2(m): "Unorganised worker" means a home-based worker, self-employed worker or wage worker in the unorganised sector, and includes a worker in the organised sector not covered by other Acts.
  • Section 3: Central Government formulates welfare schemes on life and disability cover, health and maternity benefits, old age protection and any other benefit.
  • Section 4: State Governments may formulate schemes on provident fund, employment injury, housing, education, skill upgradation, funeral assistance and old-age homes.
  • Section 5: National Social Security Board (chaired by the Union Labour Minister) recommends schemes and monitors their implementation.
  • Section 6: State Social Security Boards advise State Governments on schemes.
  • Section 9: Welfare Facilitation Centres are set up to provide information and facilitate access to schemes.
  • Section 10: Registration of workers and identity cards issued by District Administration; no worker aged below 14 can be registered.
Key Sections
SectionWhat It SaysWhy It Matters
S. 2Definitions โ€” unorganised worker, home-based, self-employed, wage workerDefines beneficiaries
S. 3Schemes by Central GovernmentLife, disability, health, maternity, old age
S. 4Schemes by State GovernmentsProvident fund, housing, education, skills
S. 5National Social Security BoardApex advisory body
S. 6State Social Security BoardsState-level advisory bodies
S. 9Welfare Facilitation CentresAccess point for workers
S. 10Registration and identity cardsGateway to benefits
Case Laws
National Campaign Committee for Central Legislation on Construction Labour v. Union of India (2018):The Supreme Court directed effective implementation of welfare Boards and cess collection for construction workers, observing that social security for unorganised workers is a constitutional obligation under Articles 21, 41 and 43.
In Re: Problems and Miseries of Migrant Labourers (2020โ€“21):The Supreme Court directed registration of unorganised and migrant workers and delivery of benefits during the pandemic, emphasising the need to complete registration under the 2008 Act and to provide welfare schemes.
Last-Minute Revision
  • S.2 โ€” Home-based, self-employed, wage worker
  • S.3 โ€” Central schemes: life, disability, health & maternity, old age
  • S.4 โ€” State schemes: PF, housing, education, skills
  • S.5 โ€” National Social Security Board | S.6 โ€” State Boards
  • S.9 โ€” Welfare Facilitation Centres | S.10 โ€” ID card (age 14+)
  • Arts 41 & 43 โ€” constitutional basis
  • Now subsumed in the Code on Social Security, 2020
5-Minute Emergency Answer
Write this if running out of time

The Unorganised Workers' Social Security Act, 2008 provides social security to home-based workers, self-employed workers and wage workers in the unorganised sector, giving effect to Articles 41 and 43. Under Section 3, the Central Government frames welfare schemes covering life and disability cover, health and maternity benefits and old-age protection; under Section 4, State Governments may frame schemes on provident fund, employment injury, housing, education and skill upgradation. Section 5 establishes the National Social Security Board, headed by the Union Labour Minister, to recommend and monitor schemes, and Section 6 provides for State Boards. Section 9 provides for Welfare Facilitation Centres and Section 10 for registration and identity cards for workers aged 14 and above through the District Administration. In In Re: Problems and Miseries of Migrant Labourers (2020), the Supreme Court directed registration of unorganised workers to ensure delivery of benefits. The Act is now subsumed by the Code on Social Security, 2020.

Full Answer

1. Introduction

Over 90% of India's workforce is in the unorganised sector without access to formal social security. The Unorganised Workers' Social Security Act, 2008, enacted following the recommendations of the National Commission for Enterprises in the Unorganised Sector (NCEUS), gives effect to Articles 41 and 43 by providing for welfare schemes for such workers.

2. Definitions โ€” Section 2

  • Unorganised worker โ€” a home-based worker, self-employed worker or a wage worker in the unorganised sector, including a worker in the organised sector not covered by ESI, EPF, Maternity Benefit, Gratuity or similar Acts.
  • Home-based worker โ€” a person engaged in production of goods or services for an employer in his home or premises of his choice.
  • Self-employed worker โ€” any person not employing others for hire, not covered by organised-sector statutes.
  • Wage worker โ€” a person employed for wages in the unorganised sector, directly or through an agency.

3. Welfare Schemes โ€” Sections 3 and 4

a) Central Government โ€” Section 3

The Central Government formulates and notifies from time to time suitable welfare schemes for unorganised workers on matters relating to life and disability cover, health and maternity benefits, old-age protection and any other benefit determined by the Government. Scheme examples: Aam Aadmi Bima Yojana, Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana, National Old Age Pension Scheme.

b) State Governments โ€” Section 4

State Governments may formulate schemes relating to provident fund, employment injury benefits, housing, educational schemes for children, skill upgradation, funeral assistance and old-age homes.

4. Institutional Framework

  • Section 5 โ€” National Social Security Board, chaired by the Union Minister for Labour, with representatives of unorganised workers, employers, and the Central and State Governments. It recommends schemes, advises the Government and monitors implementation.
  • Section 6 โ€” State Social Security Boards advise State Governments and monitor state-level schemes.
  • Section 9 โ€” Welfare Facilitation Centres disseminate information on schemes and assist workers.

5. Registration โ€” Section 10

Every unorganised worker of age 14 years or above may register with the District Administration by submitting a self-declaration. The District Administration issues an identity card, which is the gateway to benefits under the schemes.

6. Evaluation and Limitations

Criticisms include that the Act is a framework Act without enforceable entitlements or a dedicated financing mechanism, leaving benefits dependent on schemes. Registration remains low, as noted in In Re: Problems and Miseries of Migrant Labourers (2020), where the Supreme Court directed completion of registration.

7. Conclusion

The Act is a significant step in extending social security to the unorganised workforce. It has now been subsumed under the Code on Social Security, 2020, which extends coverage to gig and platform workers as well.

Exam Tip: Cover definitions (S.2), Central and State schemes (S.3-4), Boards (S.5-6), and registration (S.10). Mention the Code on Social Security, 2020.
Q2
Discuss the objectives and salient features of the Karnataka Shops and Commercial Establishments Act, 1961.
10 MarksVery Important
▾
Summary💡 Easy Answer🗒 Mind Map✅ Key Points 8📖 Sections 7⚖ Cases 2⏰ Revision⚠ Emergency📝 Full Answer
Summary

The Karnataka Shops and Commercial Establishments Act, 1961 regulates the conditions of work and employment in shops and commercial establishments in Karnataka. It prescribes hours of work, weekly holidays, opening and closing hours, leave with wages, employment of young persons and women, and provides for registration, inspection and penalties. Its aim is to prevent exploitation of workers in the unorganised, commercial sector.

Easy Answer
The "shop worker's rulebook" of Karnataka
Covers shops, hotels, restaurants, theatres, offices, commercial establishments
Working Conditions
โฐ Max 9 hours/day, 48 hours/week
โ˜• Rest interval after 5 hours
๐Ÿ“… Weekly holiday for every employee
๐ŸŒ™ Opening / closing hours fixed
๐Ÿ’ฐ Overtime paid at double rate
Leave & Other Rules
๐Ÿ–๏ธ Annual leave with wages (1 day per 12 days worked)
๐Ÿค’ Sick leave & casual leave
๐Ÿง’ Restrictions on young persons (below 14 not allowed)
๐Ÿ“‹ Registration of establishment
๐Ÿ“ Notice before termination
Mind Map
Karnataka Shops & Commercial Est. Act
Registration
Every establishment registers
Every shop and commercial establishment must register with the Inspector within prescribed time and obtain a registration certificate to be displayed prominently. Changes must be intimated.
Hours of Work
9 / 48 hours; rest interval
Not more than 9 hours a day and 48 hours a week; spread-over limited (e.g., 12 hours). Interval for rest after 5 hours of work. Opening and closing hours prescribed.
Holidays & Leave
Weekly, annual, festival
One day weekly holiday; national and festival holidays; annual leave with wages; casual and sick leave. Overtime wages at twice the normal rate.
Employment & Penalties
Young persons, women, dismissal
Children below 14 prohibited; limited hours for young persons; night work restrictions for women (with safeguards). Notice of one month or wages in lieu for termination; penalties for contravention.
Key Points
  • Objective: To regulate conditions of work and employment of persons employed in shops and commercial establishments in Karnataka.
  • Coverage: Shops, commercial establishments, residential hotels, restaurants, eating houses, theatres and other places of public amusement.
  • Registration: Every establishment must be registered and the certificate displayed.
  • Hours of work: Not more than 9 hours a day and 48 hours a week; interval for rest after 5 hours.
  • Overtime: Paid at twice the ordinary rate of wages.
  • Weekly holiday: Every employee entitled to at least one day of rest in a week, plus festival and national holidays.
  • Leave: Annual leave with wages (1 day for every 12 days worked), casual leave and sick leave.
  • Protection: Children below 14 prohibited from employment; notice of one month (or wages in lieu) before termination of an employee with a minimum period of service.
Key Provisions
ProvisionWhat It SaysWhy It Matters
RegistrationEvery establishment registers with InspectorEnables inspection and enforcement
Opening/closing hoursFixed by notificationPrevents unlimited working hours
Daily/weekly hours9 hours / 48 hoursLimits exploitation
Rest intervalAfter 5 hours of workHealth protection
OvertimeDouble wage rateDiscourages excess work
Weekly holidayAt least one dayRest and recuperation
TerminationOne month notice / wages in lieuJob security
Case Laws
Express Newspapers (P) Ltd v. Union of India (1958):Though dealing with journalists, the Supreme Court recognised that regulation of working conditions for welfare of employees is a valid exercise of legislative power and falls within the ambit of reasonable restriction on business under Article 19(6).
Bijay Cotton Mills v. State of Ajmer (1955):The Court held that statutes regulating wages and conditions of work are reasonable restrictions in the interest of the general public under Article 19(6), supporting legislation like the Shops Act.
Last-Minute Revision
  • 9 hours / 48 hours โ€” daily and weekly limits
  • 5 hours โ†’ rest interval
  • Overtime โ†’ double rate
  • Weekly holiday + festival holidays
  • Annual leave โ†’ 1 day per 12 days worked
  • Registration mandatory | No child below 14
  • Termination โ†’ one month notice or wages in lieu
  • Constitutional basis: Art 19(6) reasonable restrictions
5-Minute Emergency Answer
Write this if running out of time

The Karnataka Shops and Commercial Establishments Act, 1961 regulates the conditions of work and employment in shops, commercial establishments, hotels, restaurants and places of amusement in Karnataka. Every establishment must be registered. The Act prescribes opening and closing hours, limits work to 9 hours a day and 48 hours a week, requires a rest interval after 5 hours, and mandates payment of overtime at twice the ordinary rate. Employees get a weekly holiday, festival holidays, annual leave with wages (1 day for every 12 days worked), casual and sick leave. Children below 14 cannot be employed, hours for young persons are restricted, and an employee with the prescribed service is entitled to one month's notice or wages in lieu before termination. Inspectors enforce the Act and contraventions are punishable with fine. The Supreme Court in Bijay Cotton Mills v. State of Ajmer (1955) upheld such regulation as a reasonable restriction under Article 19(6).

Full Answer

1. Introduction

The Karnataka Shops and Commercial Establishments Act, 1961 is a State welfare legislation that regulates working conditions in the commercial sector โ€” an area otherwise outside the Factories Act. It aims to protect workers from long hours, irregular holidays and arbitrary termination, giving effect to Article 42 and Article 43.

2. Objectives

  • To regulate hours of work, rest intervals, opening and closing hours.
  • To provide holidays and leave with wages.
  • To regulate employment of young persons and women.
  • To ensure security of service and payment of wages.
  • To provide an inspection and enforcement machinery.

3. Scope and Registration

The Act applies to shops, commercial establishments, residential hotels, restaurants, eating houses, theatres and other places of public amusement or entertainment. Every employer must register the establishment with the Inspector and display the certificate.

4. Hours of Work

  • No employee shall work for more than 9 hours a day or 48 hours a week.
  • A rest interval of at least half an hour after 5 hours of continuous work.
  • The spread-over (total span of the working day including intervals) is limited.
  • Overtime work is paid at twice the ordinary rate and capped per quarter.
  • Opening and closing hours are fixed by notification.

5. Holidays and Leave

  • Weekly holiday โ€” at least one whole day in a week with wages.
  • Festival and national holidays with wages.
  • Annual leave with wages โ€” one day for every 12 days of work.
  • Casual leave and sick leave as prescribed.

6. Employment of Young Persons and Women

No child below 14 years may be employed; young persons (14โ€“18) have limited hours and cannot work at night. Women's night work is permitted only with prescribed safeguards of safety, transport and consent.

7. Termination and Wages

An employee with the prescribed minimum period of service cannot be dismissed without one month's notice or wages in lieu, and must be given reasons and an opportunity of appeal. Wages must be paid on time as per the Payment of Wages Act.

8. Enforcement and Penalties

Inspectors have powers of entry, inspection and examination of records. Contravention of the Act is punishable with fine and, for repeat offences, higher fine.

9. Judicial Support

Regulation of working conditions is upheld as a reasonable restriction under Article 19(6). In Bijay Cotton Mills v. State of Ajmer (1955), the Supreme Court held that legislation regulating conditions of work is valid in the public interest.

10. Conclusion

The Act protects millions of workers in the shops and commercial sector from exploitation and gives them dignity through rest, leave and job security. Its provisions are being consolidated under the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020.

Exam Tip: Use headings โ€” Objectives, Registration, Hours, Holidays and Leave, Young Persons and Women, Termination, Penalties. Quote the figures (9/48 hours, 5-hour interval, double overtime).
Q3
Explain the objectives and salient features of the Special Economic Zones Act, 2005.
10 MarksImportant
▾
Summary💡 Easy Answer🗒 Mind Map✅ Key Points 8📖 Sections 7⚖ Cases 2⏰ Revision⚠ Emergency📝 Full Answer
Summary

The Special Economic Zones Act, 2005 provides for the establishment, development and management of Special Economic Zones (SEZs) for promotion of exports, investment and employment. SEZs are treated as foreign territory for trade operations, duties and tariffs, with tax and duty incentives for developers and units. Labour law implications โ€” exemption from certain labour inspections and the Industrial Disputes Act treating SEZ units as public utility services โ€” are a source of controversy.

Easy Answer
SEZ = A duty-free "mini foreign country" inside India
Built to boost exports and jobs through tax breaks and simple rules
Objectives (S.2)
๐Ÿ“ˆ Generate additional economic activity
๐ŸŒ Promote exports of goods & services
๐Ÿ’ต Promote domestic and foreign investment
๐Ÿ‘ท Create employment
๐Ÿ—๏ธ Develop infrastructure
Features
๐Ÿ›๏ธ Board of Approval (S.8)
๐Ÿ‘ค Development Commissioner (S.11)
๐Ÿงพ Duty-free imports, income tax holiday
โš–๏ธ Special courts for offences (S.23)
๐Ÿ”“ Single-window clearance
Mind Map
SEZ Act, 2005
Objectives
Exports, investment, jobs
S.2: generation of additional economic activity; promotion of export of goods and services; promotion of investment from domestic and foreign sources; creation of employment; development of infrastructure.
Institutions
BoA, DC, Authority
Board of Approval (S.8) approves proposals; Approval Committee (S.11) at unit level; Development Commissioner (S.11) administers each zone; Central Government notifies zones.
Incentives
Duty & tax breaks
Duty-free import and procurement; exemption from customs duty, central excise, service tax, and other levies; income tax holiday (originally 15 years, later modified); single-window clearance.
Labour Issues
Exemptions & controversy
Labour inspections by Development Commissioner (not state labour inspectors); SEZ units declared public utility services under ID Act, restricting strikes; criticism of weak enforcement and worker rights.
Key Points
  • Objectives (S.2): Additional economic activity, export promotion, investment, employment, and infrastructure development.
  • Nature of SEZ: A specifically delineated duty-free enclave treated as foreign territory for trade operations, duties and tariffs.
  • Section 3: Central Government, State Government or any person may apply to establish an SEZ.
  • Section 8: Board of Approval considers proposals; Development Commissioner administers the zone (S.11).
  • Section 26: Exemptions from customs duty, excise, service tax and other taxes for developers and units.
  • Section 23: Provision for Special Courts to try offences.
  • Labour law angle: Powers of labour inspection vested in the Development Commissioner; SEZ units are declared public utility services under the Industrial Disputes Act.
  • Criticism: Tax revenue loss, land acquisition, farmer displacement, and weak enforcement of labour rights.
Key Sections
SectionWhat It SaysWhy It Matters
S. 2Definitions, including "Special Economic Zone"Defines the enclave
S. 3Establishment of SEZWho may apply
S. 8Board of ApprovalApproves proposals
S. 11Development CommissionerAdministers the zone
S. 23Designated CourtsSpeedy trial of offences
S. 26Exemptions, drawbacks, concessionsIncentive structure
S. 49Power to modify application of lawsLabour laws may be modified
Case Laws
Rajendra Singh v. State of Haryana โ€” SEZ land acquisition (various):Courts have scrutinised land acquisition for SEZs, holding that acquisition must serve a public purpose and fair compensation and rehabilitation must be provided to affected farmers.
Kerala Hotels & Restaurants Association v. State (concept โ€” freedom of trade):Reiterates that regulatory and incentive measures for economic zones must satisfy reasonableness under Article 19(1)(g) and the equality test of Article 14.
Last-Minute Revision
  • Objectives: activity, exports, investment, jobs, infrastructure (S.2)
  • Duty-free enclave = foreign territory for trade
  • S.8 BoA | S.11 Development Commissioner | S.23 Special Courts | S.26 exemptions
  • Labour: inspections by DC; SEZ units = public utility services
  • Criticism: revenue loss, land acquisition, weak labour rights
5-Minute Emergency Answer
Write this if running out of time

The Special Economic Zones Act, 2005 provides for the establishment, development and management of SEZs for promotion of exports. The objectives under Section 2 are generating additional economic activity, promoting exports of goods and services, promoting domestic and foreign investment, creating employment and developing infrastructure. An SEZ is a duty-free enclave treated as foreign territory for trade operations, duties and tariffs. Under Section 3 the Central or State Government or any person may establish an SEZ; the Board of Approval (S.8) approves proposals and the Development Commissioner (S.11) administers each zone. Section 26 gives exemptions from customs duty, excise and service tax, and Section 23 provides for Special Courts. From the labour law angle, labour inspection is vested in the Development Commissioner and SEZ units are declared public utility services under the ID Act, restricting strikes. Critics point to loss of revenue, displacement and weak enforcement of labour rights.

Full Answer

1. Introduction

Following the success of Export Processing Zones, India introduced the Special Economic Zones Act, 2005 (effective Feb 2006) to provide a stable and internationally competitive environment for exports. An SEZ is a specifically delineated duty-free enclave deemed to be foreign territory for the purposes of trade operations, duties and tariffs.

2. Objectives โ€” Section 2

  • Generation of additional economic activity.
  • Promotion of exports of goods and services.
  • Promotion of investment from domestic and foreign sources.
  • Creation of employment opportunities.
  • Development of infrastructure facilities.

3. Establishment and Administration

  • Section 3 โ€” Any person, State Government or Central Government may propose to set up an SEZ; the Central Government notifies it.
  • Section 8 โ€” Board of Approval (apex body) considers proposals for establishment of SEZs and units.
  • Section 11 โ€” Development Commissioner exercises administrative control over each zone and its units.

4. Incentives โ€” Section 26

Developers and units enjoy exemptions from customs duty, central excise, service tax and other levies on import and procurement, an income-tax holiday under the Income Tax Act (with later modifications), and single-window clearance.

5. Special Courts โ€” Section 23

The Central Government, with the Chief Justice of the High Court, may designate Special Courts for speedy trial of offences under the Act.

6. Labour Law in SEZs

  • The Development Commissioner is the authority to administer labour laws in the zone, replacing State labour inspectors in many respects.
  • SEZ units are declared public utility services under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, requiring notice before strikes.
  • Section 49 empowers the Central Government to modify the application of any law in an SEZ, raising concerns on diluted labour protection.

7. Criticism

Critics highlight loss of tax revenue, forced land acquisition and displacement of farmers, real-estate speculation, and weak enforcement of labour rights including limited trade union activity and contractualisation.

8. Conclusion

SEZs have boosted exports and employment but must be balanced with fair land acquisition, environmental safeguards and robust protection of workers' rights, ensuring that economic zones do not become zones of labour law exemption.

Exam Tip: Always link SEZs to labour law โ€” mention the Development Commissioner's role and public utility status under the ID Act.
Q4
Discuss the effects of Globalisation, Privatisation and the New Economic Policy on Indian labour and industry.
10 MarksImportant
▾
Summary💡 Easy Answer🗒 Mind Map✅ Key Points 8📖 Provisions 5⚖ Cases 3⏰ Revision⚠ Emergency📝 Full Answer
Summary

The New Economic Policy of 1991 introduced Liberalisation, Privatisation and Globalisation (LPG) in India. It opened the economy to foreign investment, reduced licensing, and disinvested public sector units. For labour, it brought greater flexibility, contractualisation and informalisation, voluntary retirement schemes, reduced union bargaining power, and pressure to reform labour laws, while also creating new employment opportunities in services and exports.

Easy Answer
1991 = India opened its economy: LPG
Liberalisation + Privatisation + Globalisation
Positive effects
โœ… New jobs in IT, services, exports
โœ… Higher wages in skilled sectors
โœ… Investment, technology & competitiveness
โœ… Consumer choice and growth
Negative effects
โŒ Contractualisation & casual jobs
โŒ Retrenchment and VRS pressure
โŒ Weaker trade unions
โŒ Growth of unorganised sector
โŒ Job insecurity & wage inequality
💡 Memory Trick: "LPG = Jobs UP, Security DOWN"
Growth created new jobs but replaced permanent employment with contract, casual and informal work.
Mind Map
New Economic Policy 1991 (LPG)
Liberalisation
De-licensing, open markets
Abolition of industrial licensing, reduction in import tariffs, relaxation of MRTP limits, and ease of entry for private and foreign firms. Increased competition.
Privatisation
Disinvestment of PSUs
Sale of government equity in public sector units, closure of sick units, voluntary retirement schemes, and restructuring that reduced public sector jobs.
Globalisation
Integration with world economy
FDI, WTO commitments, MNCs, outsourcing and export-oriented units; global competition drives cost-cutting and flexible labour practices.
Labour Impact
Flexibility, informalisation
Rise in contract and casual labour; decline in union density; Chapter V-B restrictions criticised; demand for hire-and-fire; labour code reforms; informalisation of formal jobs.
Key Points
  • NEP 1991 introduced Liberalisation, Privatisation and Globalisation after the balance of payments crisis.
  • Industrial policy: Abolition of licensing, relaxation of MRTP Act, FDI liberalisation, reduced public sector monopoly.
  • Privatisation: Disinvestment of PSUs, closure of sick units, and Voluntary Retirement Schemes (VRS).
  • Employment pattern: Growth of services and IT, but rise in contract, casual and informal employment.
  • Labour flexibility: Pressure for relaxing Chapter V-B of the ID Act (prior permission for layoff, retrenchment and closure) and for easier hire-and-fire.
  • Trade unions: Declining bargaining power and union density; rise of enterprise-level bargaining.
  • Social security gap: Informal workers outside protection, leading to laws like the Unorganised Workers' Act, 2008.
  • Reforms: Consolidation of labour laws into four Labour Codes (Wages, Industrial Relations, Social Security, OSH).
Key Provisions
ProvisionWhat It SaysWhy It Matters
Art 19(1)(g)Freedom of trade and businessBasis of liberalised private enterprise
Art 43Living wage and decent conditionsDirective to protect workers amid reforms
Art 43AWorkers' participation in managementCounterweight to privatisation
ID Act, Ch. V-BPrior permission for layoff / closure (100+ workers)Target of flexibility debate
ID Act, S.25-OClosure of undertakingsRestriction on exit
Case Laws
Balco Employees' Union v. Union of India (2002):The Supreme Court upheld the Government's disinvestment policy for BALCO, holding that privatisation is a policy matter and courts will not interfere, though employees' interests must be protected as per legal safeguards.
Delhi Transport Corporation v. DTC Mazdoor Congress (1991):The Court struck down arbitrary "termination without reasons" rules and upheld workers' right to security of service, emphasising that public sector employees' job security is protected by Arts 14 and 21.
Excel Wear v. Union of India (1978):The Court struck down the ID Act provision requiring government permission for closure, but later cases and amendments restored restrictions (Chapter V-B), reflecting the tension between flexibility and worker protection.
Last-Minute Revision
  • LPG (1991) โ€” Liberalisation, Privatisation, Globalisation
  • Positive: jobs in IT/services, investment, technology
  • Negative: contractualisation, VRS, informalisation, weak unions
  • Chapter V-B โ€” prior permission for layoff/retrenchment/closure in 100+ worker units
  • Balco (2002) โ€” disinvestment is a policy matter
  • Response: Unorganised Workers' Act 2008; four Labour Codes
5-Minute Emergency Answer
Write this if running out of time

The New Economic Policy of 1991 introduced Liberalisation, Privatisation and Globalisation (LPG) in India. Liberalisation removed industrial licensing and opened markets; privatisation involved disinvestment of public sector units and voluntary retirement schemes; globalisation integrated India with the world economy through FDI, WTO commitments and outsourcing. Positive effects include growth of IT and services, new employment, investment, technology and competitiveness. Negative effects on labour include contractualisation, casualisation and informalisation, retrenchment and VRS pressure, weaker trade unions, wage inequality and job insecurity, with demands to relax Chapter V-B of the Industrial Disputes Act. In Balco Employees' Union v. Union of India (2002), the Supreme Court upheld disinvestment as a matter of policy. The State's response includes the Unorganised Workers' Social Security Act, 2008 and consolidation of labour laws into four Labour Codes.

Full Answer

1. Introduction

Facing a severe balance-of-payments crisis in 1991, India adopted the New Economic Policy, built on three pillars: Liberalisation, Privatisation and Globalisation (LPG). These transformed Indian industry and, with it, industrial relations and labour law.

2. Components of the New Economic Policy

  • Liberalisation โ€” abolition of industrial licensing, relaxation of the MRTP Act, reduction of tariffs, ease of entry for private and foreign investors.
  • Privatisation โ€” disinvestment of public sector undertakings, closure or revival of sick units, and Voluntary Retirement Schemes.
  • Globalisation โ€” integration with the global economy through FDI, WTO commitments, multinational enterprises and outsourcing.

3. Positive Effects

  • Rapid growth in the IT, services and export sectors creating new employment, especially for skilled workers.
  • Inflow of investment and technology, improving productivity and competitiveness.
  • Higher wages and improved working conditions in modern sectors.

4. Negative Effects on Labour

  • Contractualisation and casualisation โ€” replacement of permanent workers with contract labour, raising issues under the Contract Labour Act.
  • Informalisation โ€” growth of unorganised employment without social security.
  • Retrenchment and VRS โ€” downsizing in public and private sectors; pressure on job security.
  • Weakened trade unions โ€” decline in union density and collective bargaining power.
  • Wage inequality and job insecurity.

5. Impact on Labour Law

Industry has demanded labour market flexibility, particularly relaxation of Chapter V-B of the Industrial Disputes Act (government permission for layoff, retrenchment and closure in establishments with 100 or more workers). The tension is seen in Excel Wear v. Union of India (1978), and later policy shifts. The Supreme Court in Balco Employees' Union v. Union of India (2002) treated disinvestment as a policy matter.

6. State Response

  • The Unorganised Workers' Social Security Act, 2008 to cover informal workers.
  • Special Economic Zones with special labour regimes.
  • Consolidation of 29 labour laws into four Labour Codes: Wages, Industrial Relations, Social Security, and Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions.

7. Conclusion

Globalisation has expanded opportunities but also exposed labour to insecurity. The challenge is to balance economic growth with the constitutional promises of Articles 21, 41, 42 and 43 โ€” ensuring that flexibility is accompanied by social security and decent work.

Exam Tip: Present a balanced answer โ€” define LPG, then positive and negative effects, then labour law impact and State response.
Share