← All resources Sem 5 · Problem Answers

Interpretation of Statutes — Practical Problem Answers

Unit 1 — Meaning and Object of Interpretation; Commencement, Operation and Repeal of Statutes

2 problems from past KSLU papers. Click any question to view the full FILAD answer.

P1 Parliament passes an Act which is to come into force on a date to be notified by the Central Government. A commits the prohibited act before notification. Can he be punished?
Primary Problem: An Act which creates a new offence receives the President’s assent on 1 March and is published in the Gazette. Section 1 says that it “shall come into force on such date as the Central Government may, by notification, appoint”. The Central Government notifies 1 July as the date. ‘A’ does the prohibited act on 20 March. Is he liable to be punished?
📝 Practice problem — framed from topics asked in past KSLU papers:
  • Apr 2021: Q.2(a) — essay: “Explain the rules relating to commencement of statute.”

Marks: 10 · Method: FILAD (Facts → Issues → Law → Application → Decision)

1. Facts of the Problem

  • The Act received assent on 1 March, and its commencement section leaves the date to a notification.
  • The Government notified 1 July as the date of commencement.
  • A did the prohibited act on 20 March, between assent and commencement.

2. Issues Involved

  • From which date does the Act operate: assent, publication or notified commencement?
  • Can A be punished for an act done before the commencement?

3. Relevant Statutory Provisions

  • Section 5, General Clauses Act, 1897: a Central Act, unless a different commencement is provided, comes into operation on the day it receives the assent of the President, and where it provides for commencement by notification, it comes into operation on the notified date.
  • Article 20(1), Constitution: no person shall be convicted of any offence except for violation of a law in force at the time of the commission of the act charged as an offence.

4. Legal Principles & Judicial Rule

  • An Act becomes law on assent, but where the Act itself leaves its commencement to a notification, its operative provisions are in abeyance until that date.
  • A penal statute has no retrospective effect to create an offence. An act is an offence only if it was an offence when it was done.

5. Application to the Present Problem

  • The Act is to come into force only on the date notified, namely 1 July. Until then its provisions do not operate.
  • A’s act on 20 March was done before 1 July, when the offence did not exist, so it was not a violation of a law in force.
  • Punishing A would breach Article 20(1) and the rule against retrospective penal laws.

6. Decision / Conclusion

A cannot be punished. The Act commenced on 1 July, the notified date, and A’s act on 20 March was not an offence when it was done.

Ratio Decidendi: Where an Act provides for commencement by notification, it operates only from the notified date; no one can be punished for an act done before it, whether or not the Act has received assent.
P2 Act X, which punishes hoarding, is repealed by Act Y. A is being tried for hoarding committed before the repeal. Does the repeal end the case?
Primary Problem: Act X punishes hoarding of essential commodities with imprisonment. ‘A’ is charged for hoarding committed under Act X, and while the trial is pending, Act X is repealed by Act Y, which has no savings clause. A argues that, since the Act under which he is charged no longer exists, the prosecution must end. Decide.
📝 Practice problem — framed from topics asked in past KSLU papers:
  • Dec 2018: Q.5 — essay: “Discuss the consequences of a repeal of a statute.”

Marks: 10 · Method: FILAD (Facts → Issues → Law → Application → Decision)

1. Facts of the Problem

  • A is being prosecuted under Act X for an act done while Act X was in force.
  • Act X is repealed during the trial by Act Y, which has no express saving.

2. Issues Involved

  • What is the effect of repeal on pending proceedings and offences already committed?

3. Relevant Statutory Provisions

  • Section 6, General Clauses Act, 1897: unless a different intention appears, a repeal shall not (a) revive anything not in force; (b) affect the previous operation of the repealed enactment or anything duly done or suffered under it; (c) affect any right, privilege, obligation or liability acquired, accrued or incurred under it; (d) affect any penalty, forfeiture or punishment incurred in respect of any offence committed against it; or (e) affect any investigation, legal proceeding or remedy in respect of such right, penalty or punishment, which may be instituted, continued or enforced as if the repealing Act had not been passed.
  • Article 20(1), Constitution: protects against conviction under a law not in force at the time of the act, but does not apply where the offence existed when committed.

4. Legal Principles & Judicial Rule

  • Under the common law, a repeal wiped out the statute as if it had never existed, so pending proceedings abated. Section 6 changes this, and saves what had already accrued unless the repealing Act shows a contrary intention — State of Punjab v. Mohar Singh (AIR 1955 SC 84).
  • A mere repeal and re-enactment, without a contrary intention, does not affect pending proceedings. The same principle governs the replacement of the IPC by the BNS.

5. Application to the Present Problem

  • A’s liability arose when he hoarded the goods, under Act X, which was then in force.
  • Act Y does not show an intention to wipe out pending proceedings, because there is no provision that says so.
  • Section 6(d) and (e) preserve the penalty incurred and allow the proceeding to continue as if Act X had not been repealed.

6. Decision / Conclusion

The repeal does not end the prosecution. A can still be tried and punished under Act X, by virtue of Section 6 of the General Clauses Act, since no contrary intention appears in Act Y.

Ratio Decidendi: Repeal does not affect pending proceedings or liabilities already incurred, unless the repealing Act shows a contrary intention (Section 6, General Clauses Act).
Share on WhatsApp