← All resources Sem 5 · Problem Answers

CPC & Limitation Act — Practical Problem Answers

Unit 1 — Jurisdiction, Foreign Judgments, Place of Suing, Transfer of Suits

5 problems from past KSLU papers. Click any question to view the full FILAD answer.

P1 Sunil (Davanagere) took a loan from Prakash (Shivamogga) at Davanagere and has not repaid it. Prakash sues him for recovery at Shivamogga. Sunil objects to the jurisdiction. Decide.
Primary Problem: Sunil is a permanent resident of Davanagere and Prakash is a permanent resident of Shivamogga. Sunil has taken a loan from Prakash at Davanagere and has not repaid it. Prakash has instituted a suit for recovery of the loan against Sunil at Shivamogga. Sunil has raised an objection as to jurisdiction. Decide.
📋 Where this appeared in past KSLU papers:
  • Dec 2018: Q.9(a) — this problem (Sunil and Prakash)

Marks: 10 (Q.9 — any two of three) · Method: FILAD (Facts → Issues → Law → Application → Decision)

1. Facts of the Problem

  • Defendant Sunil permanently resides at Davanagere; plaintiff Prakash permanently resides at Shivamogga.
  • The loan was taken at Davanagere and has not been repaid.
  • Prakash sued at Shivamogga, and Sunil objected to the territorial jurisdiction of that Court.

2. Issues Involved

  • Which Court has territorial jurisdiction in a suit for recovery of money: that of the plaintiff’s residence, the defendant’s residence, or the place where the cause of action arose?
  • Is the objection of Sunil sustainable, and what is its effect?

3. Relevant Statutory Provisions

  • Section 20, C.P.C.: Subject to the limitations in Sections 15 to 19, every suit shall be instituted in a Court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction (a) the defendant (or each of the defendants) at the time of commencement of the suit actually and voluntarily resides, carries on business or personally works for gain; or (b) any of the defendants resides, carries on business or personally works for gain (with leave of the Court, or if the other defendants acquiesce); or (c) the cause of action wholly or in part arises.
  • Section 21: an objection to the place of suing must be taken at the earliest opportunity, and before the issues are settled.
  • Order VII Rule 10: where the plaint is filed in a Court that lacks jurisdiction, it must be returned to be presented to the proper Court.

4. Legal Principles & Judicial Rule

  • The residence of the plaintiff is irrelevant under Section 20. The suit lies where the defendant resides or carries on business, or where the cause of action arises.
  • Cause of action is the bundle of facts which the plaintiff must prove to get relief — ABC Laminart (P) Ltd v. A.P. Agencies (1989) 2 SCC 163. In a loan suit, it arises where the loan was advanced, and also where, by the contract, the loan was to be repaid.
  • Parties can by agreement choose between Courts that already have jurisdiction, but cannot confer jurisdiction on a Court that has none — Hakam Singh v. Gammon (India) Ltd (1971) 1 SCC 286.

5. Application to the Present Problem

  • Sunil resides at Davanagere, so a Court at Davanagere has jurisdiction under Section 20(a).
  • The loan was taken at Davanagere, so part of the cause of action arose there under Section 20(c). Nothing in the problem shows that any part of the cause of action arose at Shivamogga, for example that the contract required repayment there.
  • Prakash’s residence at Shivamogga gives the Shivamogga Court no jurisdiction. The objection was raised at the first opportunity, so Section 21 does not defeat it.

6. Decision / Conclusion

Sunil’s objection is valid. The Court at Shivamogga lacks territorial jurisdiction, and the plaint should be returned under Order VII Rule 10 for presentation before the competent Court at Davanagere. The suit is not dismissed. The position would differ only if the contract fixed Shivamogga as the place of repayment.

Ratio Decidendi: A suit for money lies where the defendant resides or where the cause of action arises (Section 20). The plaintiff’s residence does not confer jurisdiction.
P2 A sues B in a foreign court and the suit is dismissed. A wants to file the same suit against B in India on the same cause of action. Can he?
Primary Problem: ‘A’ sues ‘B’ in a foreign court. The suit is dismissed. Thereafter ‘A’ wants to file the same suit against ‘B’ in India on the same cause of action. Whether he can institute a suit? Decide.
📋 Where this appeared in past KSLU papers:
  • Dec 2018: Q.9(b) — this problem

Marks: 10 (Q.9 — any two of three) · Method: FILAD (Facts → Issues → Law → Application → Decision)

1. Facts of the Problem

  • A sued B in a foreign court on a cause of action, and the suit was dismissed.
  • A now wants to file the same suit against B in India on the same cause of action.

2. Issues Involved

  • Is the foreign judgment of dismissal conclusive between A and B under Section 13 C.P.C.?
  • Is a fresh suit in India barred?

3. Relevant Statutory Provisions

  • Section 13, C.P.C.: A foreign judgment is conclusive as to any matter thereby directly adjudicated upon between the same parties, except where it (a) was not pronounced by a Court of competent jurisdiction; (b) has not been given on the merits of the case; (c) appears on the face of the proceedings to be founded on an incorrect view of international law or a refusal to recognise Indian law applicable; (d) was obtained in proceedings opposed to natural justice; (e) was obtained by fraud; or (f) sustains a claim founded on a breach of any law in force in India.
  • Section 14: the Court shall presume, on production of a certified copy, that a foreign judgment was pronounced by a Court of competent jurisdiction, unless the contrary appears on the record (this can be rebutted by proof that the Court lacked jurisdiction).
  • Section 11: the principle of res judicata, which Section 13 extends to foreign judgments.

4. Legal Principles & Judicial Rule

  • A judgment is “on the merits” only if the Court applied its mind to the truth or falsity of the claim, on evidence or admission. A dismissal for default, technical or procedural reasons is not a decision on the merits — Moloji Nar Singh Rao v. Shankar Saran (AIR 1962 SC 1737).
  • A decree passed without considering evidence, for example a default or summary decree, is not on the merits — International Woolen Mills v. Standard Wool (UK) Ltd (2001) 5 SCC 265.
  • Competence of the foreign Court in the international sense (for example, the defendant’s residence or submission) is examined — R. Viswanathan v. Rukn-ul-Mulk Syed Abdul Wajid (AIR 1963 SC 1).

5. Application to the Present Problem

  • If the foreign Court was competent and dismissed A’s suit on the merits after considering the evidence, the judgment is conclusive under Section 13 between A and B. A cannot re-litigate the same cause of action in India, as the matter is, in effect, res judicata.
  • If the foreign Court dismissed the suit on a technical ground, such as default, want of jurisdiction or a procedural defect, or if one of the exceptions (a) to (f) applies, the judgment is not conclusive, and A may file a fresh suit in India.

6. Decision / Conclusion

A cannot sue again if the foreign Court was competent and dismissed the suit on the merits, as Section 13 makes the judgment conclusive. He can sue in India if the dismissal was not on the merits or falls within any exception to Section 13. The answer depends on the ground of dismissal.

Ratio Decidendi: Under Section 13, a foreign judgment on the merits by a competent Court is conclusive and bars a fresh suit in India on the same cause of action; a judgment not on the merits has no such effect.
P3 Rajan sues his wife Rajani in a Civil Court at Dharwad. She lives with her parents at Tumakuru, has no income, and finds it difficult to travel to Dharwad. Advise her.
Primary Problem: Rajan has instituted a suit against his wife Rajani in the Civil Court at Dharwad. Rajani is residing at Tumakuru with her parents. She has no income of her own and therefore she is finding it difficult to travel to Dharwad frequently to attend the proceedings. Advise her.
📋 Where this appeared in past KSLU papers:
  • Dec 2020: Q.9(a) — this problem
  • Apr 2021 / Nov 2021: Q.2(a) — essay on rules for transfer of suits

Marks: 10 (Q.9 — any two of three) · Method: FILAD (Facts → Issues → Law → Application → Decision)

1. Facts of the Problem

  • Rajan sued his wife Rajani in the Civil Court at Dharwad.
  • Rajani lives with her parents at Tumakuru, and has no income of her own.
  • Frequent travel to Dharwad to attend the proceedings is difficult for her.

2. Issues Involved

  • Can the suit be transferred from Dharwad to a Court at Tumakuru?
  • Which authority can order the transfer, and on what grounds?

3. Relevant Statutory Provisions

  • Section 24, C.P.C.: on the application of any of the parties, and after notice to the parties and hearing them, the High Court or the District Court may (a) transfer any suit, appeal or other proceeding pending before it, or (b) withdraw any suit pending in a Court subordinate to it and try it or transfer it to another Court competent to try it. A District Court can transfer only within its own district.
  • Section 25: the Supreme Court may transfer a suit from a Court in one State to a Court in another State, if satisfied that it is expedient for the ends of justice.
  • Section 21A, Hindu Marriage Act, 1955: transfer of matrimonial petitions, where the proceeding is under that Act.

4. Legal Principles & Judicial Rule

  • The test for transfer is whether the ends of justice require it, and the convenience of the parties is a main consideration. In matrimonial matters, the convenience of the wife is generally given weight, particularly where she is financially weak and has to travel to a distant Court — Sumita Singh v. Kumar Sanjay (2002) 1 SCC 168; Anindita Das v. Srijit Das (2006) 9 SCC 197.
  • Transfer is not granted for mere inconvenience, but it is granted where there is real hardship or a likelihood of denial of a fair hearing — Kulwinder Kaur v. Kandi Friends Education Trust (2008) 3 SCC 659.

5. Application to the Present Problem

  • Dharwad and Tumakuru are in different districts of Karnataka, so a District Court cannot transfer the suit; the application should be made to the High Court of Karnataka under Section 24 (Section 25 would apply only if the Courts were in different States).
  • Rajani can show real hardship: she has no income, she is staying with her parents at Tumakuru, and the repeated trips to Dharwad are costly and difficult. Rajan, as the husband, who chose to sue at Dharwad, has the means to travel.
  • She should apply for transfer of the suit to the competent Court at Tumakuru, and ask for notice to Rajan and for interim directions on expenses if needed.

6. Decision / Conclusion

Rajani should file an application under Section 24 C.P.C. before the High Court of Karnataka for transfer of the suit from Dharwad to the competent Court at Tumakuru. In view of her financial position and the convenience of the wife, the transfer will normally be allowed.

Ratio Decidendi: On an application of a party, the High Court may transfer a suit under Section 24 in the interest of justice. Courts give special weight to the convenience of a financially weak wife.
P4 Anil, resident of Bellary, publishes a newspaper with statements defamatory of Basant. It circulates in Bidar, Bellary, Kalaburgi and Raichur. Where can Basant sue?
Primary Problem: Anil, who is a resident of Bellary, publishes a newspaper containing statements defamatory of Basant. The newspaper is circulated in Bidar, Bellary, Kalaburgi and Raichur. Basant desires to institute a suit against Anil. Where can he institute the suit?
📋 Where this appeared in past KSLU papers:
  • Jul 2019: Q.9(a) — this problem
  • Nov 2021: Q.1(b) — ‘A’ residing in Delhi publishes in Calcutta defamatory statements to ‘B’; newspaper circulated in Bombay, Madras and Raipur; where can ‘B’ sue?

Marks: 10 (Q.9 — any two of three); 6 in the 2021 paper · Method: FILAD (Facts → Issues → Law → Application → Decision)

1. Facts of the Problem

  • Anil resides in Bellary and publishes a newspaper containing defamatory statements about Basant.
  • The newspaper circulates in Bidar, Bellary, Kalaburgi and Raichur.
  • Basant wants to sue Anil for defamation.

2. Issues Involved

  • Where can a suit for compensation for defamation (a wrong to the person) be instituted?
  • Does Basant have a choice among the places of circulation?

3. Relevant Statutory Provisions

  • Section 19, C.P.C.: Where a suit is for compensation for wrong done to the person or to movable property, if the wrong was done within the local limits of the jurisdiction of one Court and the defendant resides, or carries on business, or personally works for gain, within the local limits of another Court, the suit may be instituted at the option of the plaintiff in either of the said Courts.
  • Illustration (b) to Section 19: A, residing in Delhi, publishes in Calcutta statements defamatory of B. B may sue A either in Calcutta or in Delhi.
  • Section 20(c): the cause of action wholly or in part arises.

4. Legal Principles & Judicial Rule

  • The wrong of defamation is complete where the defamatory matter is published and read (communicated to a third person). Each place where the newspaper is circulated and read is a place where the wrong is done, at least in part.
  • The plaintiff has an option; the defendant’s residence is one place, and the place of the wrong is another. The plaintiff’s own residence is not a ground of jurisdiction.

5. Application to the Present Problem

  • Anil resides at Bellary, which is the place of his residence (Sections 19 and 20(a)), so Basant can sue at Bellary.
  • The newspaper was published and circulated in Bidar, Kalaburgi and Raichur, so the wrong was done in each of those places as well. Basant may sue in any of those Courts.
  • Basant may choose the Court that is most convenient, but he should file only one suit on the whole of the cause of action (Order II Rule 2).

6. Decision / Conclusion

Basant may institute the suit at his option in the Court at Bellary (where Anil resides) or in the Courts at Bidar, Kalaburgi or Raichur, where the defamatory newspaper was circulated and the wrong was done, subject to the pecuniary jurisdiction of the Court.

Ratio Decidendi: Under Section 19, for a wrong to the person, the plaintiff may sue where the wrong was done or where the defendant resides. For defamation, the wrong is done where the publication is read.
P5 Rajesh sues Shekhar for Rs. 1 lakh in the Court of the Senior Civil Judge. The suit is tried, and at the stage of arguments Shekhar contends that the Court has no jurisdiction. Decide.
Primary Problem: Rajesh has instituted a suit against Shekhar for recovery of Rs. 1 lakh in the Court of Senior Civil Judge. The suit is tried by the Court and at the stage of arguments Shekhar contends that the Court has no jurisdiction to decide the case. Decide.
📋 Where this appeared in past KSLU papers:
  • Dec 2019: Q.9(a) — this problem

Marks: 10 (Q.9 — any two of three) · Method: FILAD (Facts → Issues → Law → Application → Decision)

1. Facts of the Problem

  • Rajesh filed a suit for recovery of Rs. 1 lakh in the Court of the Senior Civil Judge.
  • The Court tried the suit; at the stage of arguments Shekhar raised the objection that the Court has no jurisdiction.

2. Issues Involved

  • Can an objection to jurisdiction be raised for the first time at the stage of arguments?
  • Does the nature of the defect (territorial, pecuniary or inherent) make a difference?

3. Relevant Statutory Provisions

  • Section 21, C.P.C.: No objection as to the place of suing shall be allowed by any appellate or revisional Court unless it was taken in the Court of first instance at the earliest possible opportunity and, in all cases where issues are settled, at or before such settlement, and unless there has been a consequent failure of justice. A similar rule applies to objections to the competence of a Court with reference to its pecuniary limits (Section 21(2)).
  • Section 15: every suit shall be instituted in the Court of the lowest grade competent to try it.
  • Section 11, Suits Valuation Act, 1887: objections to over- or under-valuation of a suit are not entertained on appeal unless raised early and prejudice is shown.

4. Legal Principles & Judicial Rule

  • Objections to territorial or pecuniary jurisdiction are waivable. They must be taken at the first opportunity and before the issues are settled, failing which they are treated as waived — Hira Lal Patni v. Kali Nath (AIR 1962 SC 199).
  • A defect of inherent jurisdiction (over the subject matter) goes to the root of the matter and cannot be waived by consent; the decree is then a nullity — Kiran Singh v. Chaman Paswan (AIR 1954 SC 340). But, even then, a decree is not to be set aside solely for a pecuniary defect unless there is a failure of justice.
  • A suit of Rs. 1 lakh may be tried by a Senior Civil Judge (a higher Court), and Section 15 only directs that suits be filed in the lowest competent Court; instituting in a higher Court is an irregularity, not a nullity.

5. Application to the Present Problem

  • Shekhar took the objection at the stage of arguments, after the trial, and not at the earliest opportunity or before the settlement of issues. Under Section 21 the objection is deemed waived.
  • A Senior Civil Judge can try a suit of Rs. 1 lakh, and no failure of justice is shown. If the objection concerns the territorial or pecuniary limit, it is therefore too late.
  • Only if the objection were about the inherent lack of jurisdiction (for example, that a statute bars the Civil Court) could it be raised at any stage, but nothing of that kind is suggested.

6. Decision / Conclusion

Shekhar’s objection is rejected. An objection to territorial or pecuniary jurisdiction taken for the first time at the arguments stage is too late and is deemed waived under Section 21. The Court will proceed to decide the suit on its merits.

Ratio Decidendi: Objections to the place of suing or the pecuniary limit must be taken at the earliest opportunity and before issues are settled (Section 21); an objection taken at the arguments stage is waived, except for a defect of inherent jurisdiction.
Share on WhatsApp